I think I’d been expecting this to be the retelling of the Tarzan story, following in the path of The Jungle Book and Maleficent to be a live-action version of the other Tarzan movies. I was expecting it to be a Tarzan Reboot. It was not. The first time we see Tarzan in this The Legend of Tarzan, he’s dressed in a suit in his manor. This is not the story of Tarzan growing up in the jungle, it’s the story of Tarzan returning to the jungle and what happens when he does. That’s a much better story and Tarzan a much more complex character. That was unexpected – I’d gone just to see Alexander Skarsgard’s abs and I’d gotten so much more.
Part of what made this good was how good the acting was AND there was well-written dialogue to back it up. The result was a palpable chemistry between every character, most of all between Tarzan and Jane. Their relationship felt so believable and fresh. Margot Robbie was a fantastic Jane. Likewise, Christoph Waltz was such a good villain, at once relate-able and despicable. Their motivations were all shown at some point so that you could really root for the good guys and hate the bad guys. Also one thing director David Yates was able to do that I haven’t seen a lot of directors do is to have the characters go for long moments without talking or shooting. Some of the most powerful moments in this film were nearly silent for longer than I expected.
Of course not everything was perfect. There was some stretching of credulity (though I can’t actually tell you here because I don’t want to give stuff away). But these moments were few and far between and besides, this isn’t a nature documentary. I found the use of slavery was a bit weird and unsettling, even though it was roughly the right era (the American Civil War ended about 50-ish years before the events of this movie). Still, I nitpick. I had to really think to find things to criticize about this film and that’s the best I could come up with.